Column: There are no doubt arguable reasons Mercer canned Bob Hoffman, right? ... Right? (Chart: recent firings and records)

Few losing seasons. Increased local, regional, and state attention on a regular basis. National recognition and a place in college basketball lore. Young team that lost more close games than not-close games.
There is, of course, speculation on the reasons Mercer fired Bob Hoffman on Monday.
"He's not recruiting Georgia enough. The top teams in the conference have more Georgia players than him."
First, no they donât. Of the 10 players making the all-conference teams, one - uno - is an in-stater, VMI's Bubba Parham is from Virginia.
VMI finished 11-21, so ...
Second, thatâs as irrelevant as, well, you know, use your favorite analogy. Horrifically irrelevant, especially around national signing day, or any day with football.
As per the conference preseason media guide, there are 13 Georgians on SoCon rosters, and eight on the top four teams. One at Wofford (which, doggone it, has survived with only two in-state players, and four Midwesterners)
Sooo ...
The Duke-beaters of five years ago? Starting five of Georgia, Wisconsin, Colorado, Indiana, and Georgia, with top backups from North Carolina, Oklahoma, Georgia, and North Carolina.
Fans and administrators can never figure out what they want - among so very many things - in the process: either a fence around the state or recruit nationally. Asprin was invented because of fans and people in charge.
And exactly who, when you put all factors together, the athletic directors think Mercer is supposed to be, destined to be, is tough to figure out.
An academically elite college in a region where education is overly prioritized simply wonât have quite as many backyard prospects as others. Go figure why Kennesaw State is Kennesaw State and not more like Georgia State, which battled severe mediocrity for a good while. Gee, itâs so easy.
And for the love of John Wooden, who cares where the hell somebody is from if they play and practice hard, get better, and are good teammates and good citizens?
"The President hates losing."
Well, duh, who likes it? Think he hates it more than the head coach? Really?
No. He doesn't. No non-coach hates losing more than most coaches or most players.
Think Hoffman got more sleep after that UNCG game than an executive athletics director or athletics director or booster/investor? If so, on what planet might that be?
Iâve long had a motto and belief â among many â in sports, usually when a coach doesnât give a player a chance or a second chance, but increasingly when it comes to upper mismanagement: You give somebody the opportunity to fall into a hole, you have to give them a chance to get out. When a player or team is down, they need the chance to get back up.
Hoffman, stunningly, didnât get that chance, and considering his teams have never been down for long âŠ
âThe talent level is really down.â
Perhaps the talent level is debatable, veterans and youngsters. Then again, compared to what? Mercerâs past? The rest of the SoCon? You saw those up-and-down records in the first sermon on this topic, right? The conference has no out-and-out standard-bearer the last decade. Four different teams have won the last four conference tournaments and have had the best overall record: Wofford, UNCG, ETSU, and Chattanooga. Three of the four have had a losing season in the last five, ETSUâs 16-14 year in 2014-15 keeping the Bucs off that list. UNCG in 2014-15? 11-22, and 16-18 a year later.
Maybe the Spartans were young.
There is the transition to college basketball, and there is an additional transition to playing for Hoffman, who runs more stuff than the vast majority of coaches out there. You have to be smart to get into Mercer, and you have to be smart to play for Hoffman.
With so many young 'ns, sure, a rough season will appear. But when the light goes on (like it pretty much always does for most of/enough of Hoffmanâs players)? You have a couple 20-win seasons to get ready for. Unless âŠ
Too, maybe Hoffmanâs batting average in hiring assistants wasnât what it needed to be, and assistants do more recruiting than head coaches.
Perhaps a gamble didnât work out, a playerâs development stopped. It happens. Ask McKillop, whose Davidson team went from three NCAA Tournament wins to 16-15 in a year, a drop of 11 Ws.
A young team in general can look a little inferior, and a young team grasping the complexities of Hoffball will look even worse, until it looks better.
Mercer, which still can be a verb, is in better shape than it was when Hoffman took over. Obviously. Duh.
But hereâs one for you. Mark Slonaker was fired after going 128-187 in 11 years, with two winning seasons and no national postseason. Bob Hoffman was fired after going 209-165 in 11 years and winning a game in every national postseason tournament available, and having four losing seasons.
Granted, under different people in charge â another discussion for another few days - Slonaker wouldnât have gotten 11 years, no question. A change in administration, overall and in athletics, led to a change in expectations and a very, very, very, very belated increase in spending and staffing. Extraordinarily belated.
And goodness, it paid off. But thereâs still something of a âwowâ in those facts.
No, Hoffman wasnât a victim of his success â thatâs silly â but he was a victim of decision-makers who somehow think Mercer is any different than many other very similar programs, very similar schools, and that simply throwing money is all it takes. Where those folks think Mercer should be â in real reality, not what passes for reality for most anymore â is quite the question.
Is the program in a downward spiral? No. Dropping from 19 wins to 11 is a negative, but not a spiral. Winning 27 doesn't assure you forever greatness, losing 20 doesn't assure you forever failure.
Take a look at the accompanying chart of the other coaches fired (through Friday). The average yearly record of the dismissed is 13-18. Average. Hoffman: 19-15.
And then thereâs off the court, where Hoffman had become one of two faces for Mercer, the other being co-Oklahoma Baptist grad president Bill Underwood.
Hoffman worked ferociously in the world to get the Mercer name out as he did on the court to get wins. He spoke to groups, he returned calls, sent signed items, remembered all sorts of things, engaged the players in the community and on campus, and was about as well-liked among the media as you can get. He answered and returned calls, texts, and email from, well, everybody. He helped.
He marketed, and more than just Mercer hoops.
Yes, there were some in the building â and in other buildings near and not-so-near - to whom he may have been a little too gruff.
Personally: very, very few saw as much Mercer hoops for several years as me, including 2013-14, the last year I covered Mercer sports in general as things at The Old Job changed.
That season was probably the most enjoyable â even before The Win in Raleigh â six months in a career thatâs included the requisite high spots â big bowl games, World Series, Super Bowls, state and conference championships, and all that.
It was because of Hoffman, the players he brought in, and the basketball they played. Good God, it was a joyous time, and that group represented so very, very well a university that was lukewarm in general toward athletics and a community for which Mercer sports had been an afterthought. Mercer and Macon didnât necessarily deserve what that team gave them, and still does.
Their collective personality, intelligence, and energy? Wow. Thankfully, Iâll have a connection of sorts with many players on that team forever, for which Iâm grateful.
It was that good.
Sorry for this reality check, but Mercer will for our lifetimes be âBob Hoffmanâ and âDukeâ more likely than it will ever be âMercer footballâ or most anything else. Thatâs just the way it is. Frankly, barring a real collapse â like losing to Kennesaw and VMI three or four straight times - he shouldâve/couldâve been here long enough for âHoffman Court at Hawkins Arenaâ to be up for debate.
And now, for reasons only a few can really gather, Mercerâs dude of dudes is done.
Iâve never been a believer in the blank-check thing where, no, you canât fire this or that coach, he/she should be able to leave when the want. Bull. No team or coach is bigger than the school â note that Florida State and Penn State didnât close, nor did Alabama or Kentucky or UCLA, etc. - and thatâs still the case.
But really, Hoffman earned the right to stay until there was a legit spiral, 11 wins followed by 11 â or fewer - wins, and blowouts rather than close games, losing with seniors and juniors as the top seven or eight, evidence of a trend of iffy recruiting.
That wasnât the case.
Athletics director Jim Cole asked in the short statement on the firing for âthe support of the entire Mercer family as we take our menâs basketball program in a new direction.â
Theyâll need prayers, too, that the new direction the administration takes the program isnât backwards.